Introduction
Posted by Erik Kelner onUnfortunately, I spend almost as much time travelling as I do coaching. For now, there is not much I can do about that - it comes with the job.
However, I have resolved to use the travel time more productively.
For some time, I have been contemplating how to better engage with my followers. I considered making YouTube videos, but I don't do well in front of a camera. Instead, I'll focus on the written word. I like writing and it comes naturally to me. Some will argue that videos reach a far larger audience - and that is probably true - but I'll be aiming for quality over quantity.
In any case, I feel I have something to say, and I feel more comfortable putting it down in writing. That is reason enough for now.
I have therefore started this blog. I invite readers to comment and to let me know what they would like me to write about.
3 comments
-
Erik Kelner on
Hi Jason,
Thank you for the interesting and detailed question. I don’t have the time to give it the answer it deserves right now, but I’ve asked a friend – someone I’ll be working with on programming-related projects in the near future – to share his thoughts, which I largely agree with. -
Jason Harrison on
Hi Erik,
I’d love to hear your thoughts on developing maximal strength while continuing to train CrossFit.
A few questions I’d be interested in seeing covered:
1. How would you structure a strength programme alongside CrossFit without compromising progress in either?
2. If the main goal is increasing back squat, front squat, snatch and clean & jerk numbers, how many CrossFit sessions per week would you recommend?
3. During a dedicated 12-week strength block, how much conditioning should an athlete maintain without interfering with strength gains?
4. Is Zone 2 conditioning preferable to high-intensity intervals during a strength-focused training block, or is there room for both?
5. Would you recommend three dedicated weightlifting sessions alongside CrossFit, or more frequent lifting with reduced conditioning?
6. How would you manage fatigue and recovery when combining heavy squats, Olympic lifting and CrossFit metcons?
7. For an experienced CrossFit athlete with reasonable strength numbers, what would you prioritise to break through long-standing strength plateaus?Ultimately, I’m interested in how to become significantly stronger and improve my Olympic lifts while maintaining a decent level of conditioning, rather than having to sacrifice one for the other.
I’d be interested to hear how you’d approach programming this from a weightlifting coach’s perspective.
Hi Jason,
Erik asked me to take your questions, so here are my thoughts. These are good and relevant questions, and they touch on exactly the trade-offs many CrossFit athletes struggle with when they want to get stronger.
Before I answer, I should be upfront about what I don’t know: your current programme, whether you train in classes or on your own, how your technique looks, and your recovery demands outside training. These are therefore general principles rather than an individual prescription. I’m assuming your CrossFit sessions combine weightlifting, strength work and metcons.
Your main goal gives us a clear priority: develop strength and improve your Olympic lifts while maintaining a decent level of conditioning. That is different from trying to improve every aspect of CrossFit simultaneously.
The questions overlap, so I’ll explain the main principles first, then address the specific decisions.
How strength is built
Developing maximal strength and improving weightlifting performance are related, but different tasks. Increasing your squat strength may help your clean, but you also need to assess how effectively you use that strength within the lift.
Three overlapping adaptations provide a useful framework:
Coordination and skill. You get better at the movements you practise. In the snatch and clean & jerk, this includes coordinating the pull, moving under the bar and receiving it. Practising while relatively fresh gives you better conditions for repeating and improving execution. Useful technical work should address an observed limitation.
Neural adaptations. Strength training improves your nervous system’s ability to activate your muscles, including motor unit recruitment and firing frequency. During heavy strength work, try to accelerate the weight while maintaining technique. The weight may move slowly, but the intention is to move it quickly. You do not need to grind to failure or repeatedly miss lifts to progress.
Muscle mass. Building muscle increases your force-producing potential. You do not need to be completely fresh to stimulate muscle growth, but fatigue becomes a concern when it consistently limits the hard sets you can perform.
The aim is to perform appropriate training, progress it over time and recover from it. Freshness helps you do that, but eliminating fatigue is not the goal.
1. How would you structure a strength programme alongside CrossFit without compromising progress in either?
Start by treating everything as one programme. Heavy squats, high-repetition thrusters and bike intervals all load the legs, whatever they are called.
I would organise your priority lifting first, accounting for the work already included in CrossFit, then fit conditioning around it.
Where practical, separate lifting and conditioning by several hours or put them on different days. When they happen together, I would generally place priority weightlifting work first, followed by strength work and then conditioning. The order should reflect the main purpose of the session.
The same logic applies within the lifting itself. If your back squat is relatively high compared with your snatch, do the snatch before the back squat. Your technique stays sharp for the lift you want to improve, and you can still perform good, effective sets of squats afterwards.
You can develop strength while maintaining conditioning, but keeping fatigue in check is essential. The overall workload needs to allow you to perform your priority lifting consistently well and recover between sessions. If fatigue repeatedly compromises that, adjust the amount, intensity or timing of your training.
2. If the main goal is increasing back squat, front squat, snatch and clean & jerk numbers, how many CrossFit sessions per week would you recommend?
There’s no universal number, because it depends on how much training you’re already doing. Start by counting your lifting and strength sessions. If you only have three a week, one extra CrossFit session is realistic. If your week is already full of lifting and metcons, adding more probably isn’t, and the question becomes which of your current sessions to modify.
A practical way to test it: start with one hard CrossFit session per week, and at the end of the week ask yourself whether your lifting and strength sessions were affected. If they weren’t, you can consider adding a metcon after one of your lifting sessions, or a separate session, and then reassess. For most people, this lands at one to two hard sessions per week. Where to place them is covered in the next answer.
The principle behind it is simple: go into the sessions that bring you closer to your goal fresh. If you can’t, turn something down.
3 + 4. During a dedicated 12-week strength block, how much conditioning should an athlete maintain without interfering with strength gains? Is Zone 2 conditioning preferable to high-intensity intervals during a strength-focused training block, or is there room for both?
I’m taking these two questions together, because how much conditioning you can handle and which type you choose both depend on where it sits in your week.
There is room for both, because they do different jobs. In a dedicated strength block, you will most likely be doing weightlifting and strength work three to four times per week, and that leaves room for conditioning as long as you place it well.
First, not all conditioning costs the same. Hard CrossFit workouts and demanding metcons push your body harder than pure conditioning sessions, so they are likely to be more taxing. That is why they get a stricter budget, and why you can be more relaxed with easy conditioning.
Hard conditioning. This is where the budget applies: roughly one to two sessions per week, which is the same budget as the CrossFit sessions in question 2, not on top of it. A demanding metcon counts here, whatever it is called. A good rule of thumb is to place it just before a rest day. If you do weightlifting and strength on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday, put the conditioning on Wednesday, ahead of Thursday’s rest. The same goes for Saturday ahead of Sunday. That way, the fatigue has time to clear before your next priority lifting session. Experiment and see what you can handle. If you only have room for one session, choose the type that matches what you want to maintain.
Easy aerobic work. This is cheaper for the body, so you can be more flexible and fit it in where it works in your everyday life. It doesn’t count towards the budget above in the same way, but it isn’t free either: longer sessions still add workload, so keep it easy. A rest day is a good place for easy to moderate cardio, but note whether it affects how you feel in the next day’s training. If it does, move it or turn it down. Time matters too: if your weightlifting and strength sessions already take 90-120 minutes, it makes little sense to add more to the end of them. If you can fit something in the evening at home, low to moderate cardio is a good option, since it is a low-stress stimulus that is easy to recover from.
I wouldn’t automatically swap all hard conditioning for Zone 2, especially if high-intensity performance matters to you. Each session should have a purpose, not be added simply because it feels like you should be doing more.
Lastly, if your block includes a peaking phase, whether every fourth or sixth week or at the end, consider dropping conditioning in those weeks. You will likely need a lower overall workload to express your strength.
5. Would you recommend three dedicated weightlifting sessions alongside CrossFit, or more frequent lifting with reduced conditioning?
Three dedicated sessions could be a reasonable starting structure, provided their content and the surrounding training allow you to perform them well.
More frequent lifting may help if existing sessions are too long, important work gets rushed or technical quality declines towards the end. Initially, I would distribute the same weekly lifting volume across more days rather than simply add work.
That separates two decisions: whether you benefit from practising more frequently, and whether you need more total training.
The more often you lift in a week, the more often you get to practise your lifts. Take that with a grain of salt, since more is not always better. But in a dedicated strength block, I would try to train both lifts on most days, split into primary and secondary lifts. The primary lift is the snatch or the clean & jerk, and the secondary lift is a hang or power version of the other one. That way you practise often without making the snatch and the clean & jerk your main lifts every day.
The content should address your needs. Snatch, clean and jerk all deserve appropriate attention, and the jerk should not always be whatever remains after cleans.
If three sessions already provide consistent practice and progress, there is no obvious reason to add days. Reduce conditioning when its demands are preventing you from performing the lifting well, rather than simply because you have chosen a particular lifting frequency.
6. How would you manage fatigue and recovery when combining heavy squats, Olympic lifting and CrossFit metcons?
Look for overlapping demands across the week. A metcon containing substantial thruster, wall-ball or lunge volume may add more leg work than an already demanding squat programme needs.
I would also distinguish demanding days from easier ones rather than make every session a test.
Signals worth watching include familiar weights consistently feeling harder, normally reliable lifts becoming less repeatable, or an ongoing inability to complete planned training. One poor session is normal; a recurring pattern deserves a review.
The response should match the likely source, and I would start with the least disruptive change and work towards the most disruptive:
Modify a metcon: lower the load, reduce the rounds or swap the movements.
Remove sets that aren’t adding quality.
Redistribute demanding work across the week.
Introduce an easier period.
Only then drop a whole session.
This is a soft order rather than a rule. If the source is obvious, for example a metcon full of squats the day before heavy squats, fix that first.
Sleep and adequate food support recovery, but the programme itself must also be manageable.
7. For an experienced CrossFit athlete with reasonable strength numbers, what would you prioritise to break through long-standing strength plateaus?
Find the likely limitation before adding more work.
The three adaptations discussed earlier provide a framework, but experience does not tell us which aspect needs attention. Nor can all three be assessed directly by watching a lift.
First, establish what has plateaued. If your front squat keeps improving but your clean does not, I would examine the pull and receiving phase before assuming you need more squat work. If you consistently receive cleans in a sound position but cannot stand up, squat strength and accumulated fatigue deserve closer attention. Neither observation establishes the answer on its own.
Filming lifts at different loads helps show when execution changes. Technical practice should address those observations, with enough work in the full lift to assess whether the changes transfer.
If execution is consistent and strength appears to be the limitation, review exercise selection, training volume, effort and progression. Additional muscle-building work, including stable machine exercises where available, may complement your barbell training.
Finally, check consistency and recovery. A plateau may require more training, better technical practice or less fatigue from the rest of the programme. Make a targeted adjustment and evaluate the response over time.
So in conclusion, you can get stronger, improve your Olympic lifts and develop your conditioning alongside each other. Strength is built from quality work you can repeat week after week, so protect that first. Keep your priorities clear, and when fatigue repeatedly compromises your training, adjust the workload rather than push through.
I know it can be frustrating to want both at once, and there is no perfect formula. I hope you can use some of these principles in your own training. Good luck, and I’d love to hear how it goes.